1130 York Rd
Warminster, PA 18974-2012

"Here is a simple but powerful rule: always give people more than what they expect to get."

- Nelson Boswell

Payments and Claims

800-458-0811 x 3000 Erie Insurance Group
100 Erie Insurance Place
Erie, PA 16530
Online Payments
800-425-1100 Grange Insurance Companies
PO Box 740604
Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604
Online Payments
Online Payments
800-422-4272 MetLife
PO Box 41753
Philadelphia, PA 19101-1753
Online Payments
800-842-5075 Travelers
One Tower Square
Hartford, CT 06183-1001
Online Payments
888-888-0080 Foremost Insurance
PO Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
Online Payments
800-626-4751 Lititz Mutual
2 North Broad St
PO Box 1700
Lititz, PA 17543-7100
Online Payments
800-888-7764 Progressive Insurance
PO Box 4640
Carol Stream, IL 60197-9601
Online Payments

Phone: 800-367-3743
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 800-445-3030
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 888-252-2799
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 800-854-6011
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 800-252-4633
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 800-527-3907
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 855-725-5642
Website: Online Claims
Phone: 800-776-4737
Website: Online Claims

Service Center

Online Account Services

Please use our online customer service center to view your insurance policies, print insurance ID cards, update your contact information, download documents, and more.


Simply enter your account email and a secure link will be sent to you to access your account information. The link will be active for 15 minutes each time you request it so there are no passwords to remember. Of course you can always call us at 215-675-4446 or email service@careyagency.com.



24-Hour Payments and Claims Reporting:

To better assist you after hours, the following carriers have 24-hour direct claims and payment services available.